fincash logo SOLUTIONS
EXPLORE FUNDS
CALCULATORS
LOG IN
SIGN UP

Fincash » Tata India Tax Savings Vs Principal Tax Savings Fund

Tata India Tax Savings Fund Vs Principal Tax Savings Fund

Updated on July 12, 2019 , 113 views

Tata India Tax Savings Fund and Principal Tax Savings Fund both the schemes are a part of the ELSS category of Mutual Funds. ELSS or Equity Linked Savings Scheme is a type of Mutual Fund that gives investors dual benefits of investing and tax deduction. ELSS schemes predominantly invest their major stake of the fund money in equity and equity-related instruments. Individuals Investing in ELSS can claim a tax deduction of up to INR 1,50,000 under Sec. 80c of Income Tax Act, 1961. Being a tax saving instrument, ELSS has a lock-in period of three years. However, it is the shortest as compared to other tax saving avenues. Though both Tata India Tax Savings Fund and Principal Tax Savings Fund are a part of the same category, nevertheless; there are a number of differences between them. So, let’s have an in-depth understanding of these parameters.

About Tata India Tax Savings Fund

Tata India Tax Savings Fund is suitable for investors seeking appreciation in the capital in medium to long-term horizon along with benefits of tax deduction. One of the advantages of Tata India Tax Savings Fund is it selects stocks that are fundamentally good by adopting a top-down and bottom-up approach. Tata India Tax Savings Fund, based on its Asset Allocation objective invests around 80-100% of its money in equity and equity-related instruments and the remaining in fixed income and money market instruments. Mr. Rupesh Patel is the sole fund manager managing the Tata India Tax Savings Fund. This scheme of Tata Mutual Fund uses S&P BSE Sensex TRI as its base to build its basket of assets. Some of the top 10 constituents of Tata India Tax Savings Fund’s portfolio as on March 31, 2018, include HDFC Bank Limited, Kotak Mahindra Bank, Reliance Industries Limited, and Tata Motors Limited.

About Principal Tax Savings Fund

Principal Tax Savings Fund is offered and managed by Principal Mutual Fund. This scheme was incepted on March 31, 1996, and uses S&P BSE 200 Index as its benchmark to build its portfolio. Mr. P.V.K. Mohan is the fund manager managing the Principal Tax Savings Fund. The scheme aims at providing returns to its investors by way of capital appreciation. The objective of Principal Tax Savings Fund is to provide a high-quality growth-oriented portfolio that helps in attaining long-term capital gains to the investors. As per the asset allocation objective of Principal Tax Savings Fund, it invests a minimum of 80% of its pooled money in equity and equity-related instruments and a maximum of 20% of its pooled money in fixed income instruments.

Tata India Tax Savings Fund Vs Principal Tax Savings Fund

Though both Tata India Tax Savings Fund and Principal Tax Savings Fund both are a part of ELSS category, nevertheless; there differ on a number of parameters. So, let us understand the differences between these schemes by analyzing these parameters that are classified into four sections, listed below as follows.

Basics Section

Being the first section in the comparison, it includes parameters such as current NAV, scheme category, and Fincash Rating. To begin with the scheme category, it can be said that both the schemes are a part of Equity ELSS category. The comparison of Fincash Rating reveals that Tata India Tax Savings Fund is a 5-Star rated scheme and Principal Tax Savings Fund is a 4-Star rated scheme. However, there is a considerable difference in the NAV of both the schemes. As on May 02, 2018, the NAV of Tata India Tax Savings Fund is approximately INR 17 and of Principal Tax Savings Fund is around INR 219. The comparison of basics section is as follows.

Parameters
BasicsNAV
Net Assets (Cr)
Launch Date
Rating
Category
Sub Cat.
Category Rank
Risk
Expense Ratio
Sharpe Ratio
Information Ratio
Alpha Ratio
Benchmark
Exit Load
Tata India Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
₹18.244 ↓ -0.06   (-0.33 %)
₹1,790 on 30 Apr 19
13 Oct 14
Equity
ELSS
1
Moderately High
2.61
-0.05
-0.22
-11.12
Not Available
NIL
Principal Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
₹204.64 ↑ 0.27   (0.13 %)
₹406 on 30 Apr 19
31 Mar 96
Equity
ELSS
8
Moderately High
2.88
-0.51
0.09
-8.96
Not Available
NIL

Performance Section

It is the second section in the comparison that analyzes the differences in the CAGR or Compounded Annual Growth Rate of both the schemes. These CAGR returns are compared at different time intervals such as 1 Month Return, 6 Month Return, 3 Year Return, and Return since Inception. The comparison of performance section states that, in many instances, Principal Tax Savings Fund leads the race. The table given below summarizes the comparison of performance section.

Parameters
Performance1 Month
3 Month
6 Month
1 Year
3 Year
5 Year
Since launch
Tata India Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
-2.5%
1.1%
7.5%
6.4%
11.4%
0%
13.5%
Principal Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
-2.8%
-2.5%
1.3%
-0.7%
10.9%
11.6%
15.9%

Ready to Invest?
Talk to our investment specialist
Disclaimer:
By submitting this form I authorize Fincash.com to call/SMS/email me about its products and I accept the terms of Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.

Yearly Performance Section

This section compares the absolute returns generated by both the schemes for a particular year. The comparison of yearly performance section in certain years, Tata India Tax Savings Fund leads the race while for others, Principal Tax Savings Fund leads the race. The summary comparison of the absolute returns is summarized as follows.

Parameters
Yearly Performance2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
Tata India Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
-8.4%
46%
2.1%
13.3%
0%
Principal Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
-9.2%
48.8%
6.2%
2.7%
49.4%

Other Details Section

It is the last section in the comparison and includes parameters such as AUM, exit load, minimum SIP investment, and minimum lumpsum investment. The minimum SIP and lumpsum investment are same for both the schemes, that is, INR 500. With respect to the exit load, there is no exit load on both the schemes, as they are ELSS based schemes. However, both the schemes differ significantly on account of AUM. The AUM of Tata Mutual Fund’s scheme was around INR 1,267 Crores while of Principal Mutual Fund’s scheme was nearly INR 375 Crores as of March 31, 2018. The other details section is tabulated as follows.

Parameters
Other DetailsMin SIP Investment
Min Investment
Fund Manager
Tata India Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
₹500
₹500
Rupesh Patel - 3.84 Yr.
Principal Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
₹500
₹500
P.V.K. Mohan - 8.42 Yr.

Growth of 10k Investments over the years

Growth of 10,000 investment over the years.
Tata India Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
DateValue
30 Jun 15₹11,139
30 Jun 16₹12,422
30 Jun 17₹15,082
30 Jun 18₹16,166
30 Jun 19₹18,096
Growth of 10,000 investment over the years.
Principal Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
DateValue
30 Jun 14₹10,000
30 Jun 15₹11,394
30 Jun 16₹11,770
30 Jun 17₹15,249
30 Jun 18₹16,512
30 Jun 19₹16,922

Detailed portfolio Comparison

Asset Allocation
Tata India Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
Asset ClassValue
Cash5.73%
Equity94.27%
Equity Sector Allocation
SectorValue
Financial Services41.5%
Industrials11.2%
Technology9.55%
Consumer Cyclical9.38%
Consumer Defensive7.25%
Health Care6.3%
Energy5.63%
Basic Materials2.79%
Real Estate0.67%
Top Securities Holdings / Portfolio
NameHoldingValueQuantity
ICICI Bank Ltd (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 30 Nov 16 | ICICIBANK
9%₹170 Cr4,015,000
HDFC Bank Ltd (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 28 Feb 10 | HDFCBANK
7%₹136 Cr560,000
Infosys Ltd (Technology)
Equity, Since 30 Sep 18 | INFY
7%₹124 Cr1,680,000
Axis Bank Ltd (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 31 Aug 18 | 532215
6%₹121 Cr1,500,000
State Bank of India (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 30 Nov 18 | SBIN
6%₹109 Cr3,100,000
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 31 May 15 | KOTAKBANK
4%₹75 Cr495,000
Housing Development Finance Corp Ltd (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 30 Jun 17 | HDFC
4%₹74 Cr340,000
↑ 30,000
Reliance Industries Ltd (Energy)
Equity, Since 31 Jan 18 | RELIANCE
4%₹67 Cr500,000
Tata Consultancy Services Ltd (Technology)
Equity, Since 31 Jul 18 | TCS
3%₹55 Cr250,000
ITC Ltd (Consumer Defensive)
Equity, Since 30 Sep 16 | ITC
3%₹53 Cr1,900,000
Asset Allocation
Principal Tax Savings Fund
Growth
Fund Details
Asset ClassValue
Cash2.11%
Equity97.89%
Equity Sector Allocation
SectorValue
Financial Services32%
Basic Materials15.69%
Consumer Defensive11.67%
Industrials8.32%
Technology8.15%
Consumer Cyclical7.68%
Energy4.31%
Utility4.18%
Health Care4.14%
Communication Services1.75%
Top Securities Holdings / Portfolio
NameHoldingValueQuantity
HDFC Bank Ltd (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 31 Jul 09 | HDFCBANK
5%₹22 Cr91,334
ICICI Bank Ltd (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 31 Oct 09 | ICICIBANK
5%₹22 Cr509,143
Reliance Industries Ltd (Energy)
Equity, Since 31 Mar 08 | RELIANCE
4%₹18 Cr134,452
State Bank of India (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 30 Apr 05 | SBIN
4%₹17 Cr479,851
Tata Consultancy Services Ltd (Technology)
Equity, Since 30 Apr 14 | TCS
3%₹15 Cr66,040
Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd (Financial Services)
Equity, Since 31 Jan 16 | KOTAKBANK
3%₹14 Cr89,915
ITC Ltd (Consumer Defensive)
Equity, Since 29 Feb 12 | ITC
3%₹13 Cr455,396
Larsen & Toubro Ltd (Industrials)
Equity, Since 31 Mar 13 | LT
3%₹12 Cr77,262
Tata Power Co Ltd (Utilities)
Equity, Since 30 Nov 17 | 500400
3%₹11 Cr1,582,240
Marico Ltd (Consumer Defensive)
Equity, Since 31 Aug 18 | 531642
2%₹10 Cr276,100
↑ 25,100

Therefore, from the above pointers, it can be said that both the schemes differ on numerous parameters though they form part of the same category. Resultantly, individuals should be careful while choosing any of the schemes for investment. They should check whether the scheme suits their investment objective or not. They should also understand its functioning completely. If required, the opinion of a financial consultant can also be taken. These steps will help ensure that individuals attain their objectives on time and in a hassle-free manner.

Disclaimer:
All efforts have been made to ensure the information provided here is accurate. However, no guarantees are made regarding correctness of data. Please verify with scheme information document before making any investment.
How helpful was this page ?
Rated 4.5, based on 2 reviews.
POST A COMMENT